Gentrification good or bad

THE arguments for and against gentrification straddle social, political and historical barriers and aesthetic appeal alone can not determine their success.

Inevitably if people with a degree of capital move into what might be termed working-class areas and subsequently transform the properties there will be winners and losers.

The winners will be the property owners who will witness an increased value in their homes and offices. The losers will be the members of the community who live in rented accommodation, many of whom may be forced out.

In Aberdeen, the oil capital of Europe, a quite staggering housing boom left property owners and those in the oil and gas industry quids in. Suddenly the old fishermen’s cottages in the city’s Footdee area became prized assets and many were given ‘money is no-object’ makeovers. The non-oil renters not only, understandably, felt natural envy, but over time were subjected to higher daily living costs and priced out of the housing market as the local economy took on a life of its own and for a time the standard of living was second only to London.

The effect on the communities was palpable but did the stark yet striking granite skyline suffer as a result? The answer is probably no because of the surfeit of agricultural land around Aberdeenshire which was bought up and built on. New homes and business parks in many respects saved the great historical buildings from being tainted and overshadowed with the negative effects of black gold.

In areas with less geographical leeway however gentrification has been felt more acutely.

Barnsbury was built around 1820, as a middle-class London suburb, but after World War II people moved to the suburbs when the great housing demand rendered Barnsbury the place of cheap housing, where most people shared accommodation. In the late 1950s and early 1960s, people moving into the area had to finance house renovations with their money, because banks rarely financed loans for Barnsbury. Moreover, the rehabilitating spark was The 1959 Housing Purchase and Housing Act, investing £100 million to rehabilitate old properties and infrastructure. As a result, the principal population influx occurred between 1961 and 1975. Now, however it is the haven of the super-rich and was one of the places that gave rise to the term super-gentrification along with the neighboring working-class borough of Islington where Prime minister Tony Blair moved after his election victory in 1997.

For decades in London boroughs such as these generations of the same family would state proudly that they had never moved more than a few streets from where their great-grandparents once lived. With gentrification times swiftly change.

Globally the issue is enormous and comes under many guises. In Rio de Janeiro in Brazil more than 20,000 families have been removed from their homes in the past six or seven years, while 40,000 live under the threat of removal, typically for legally or ethically questionable reasons. That is why the fight for land regularisation is growing across Latin America. Gentrification there is also called ‘white removal’ or ‘market removal’ by locals, and it is only made possible through land regularisation.

Gentrification has been substantially advocated by local governments, often in the form of ‘urban restructuring’ policies. Goals of these policies include dispersing low-income residents out of the inner city and into the suburbs as well as redeveloping the city to foster mobility between both the central city and suburbia as residential options.

The strain on public resources that often accompanies concentrated poverty is relaxed by the gentrification process, a benefit of changed social makeup that is favourable for the local state.

But a change of residence that is forced upon people who lack resources to cope has social costs. Measures protecting these marginal groups from gentrification may reduce those.

There is also the argument that gentrification reduces the social capital of the area it affects. Communities have strong ties to the history and culture of their neighborhood, and causing its dispersal can have detrimental costs.

But gentrification is nothing new.

In truth evidence of it goes back centuries to ancient Rome when small shops were replaced by grand villas but for millennial purposes we go back just over half a century when British sociologist Ruth Glass coined the term to describe the influx of middle class people displacing lower class worker residents in urban neighbourhoods; her example was London and its working-class districts such as the aforementioned Islington.

At that time Britain was still recovering from a punishing war and colourfully papering over the cracks of war and the bleak post war period were actively encouraged. In that year in fact – 1964 – Terence Conran opened the first Habitat store in Fulham Road, Carnaby Street stores were enthusiastically suiting and booting young people in exotic hues and music and lights were the order of the day.

The consensus now largely is that the demise of traditional communities is rooted in those seemingly carefree days – and gentrification inevitably is the bully boy who is to blame.

But the rhythm of life will inevitably determine what happens in future as man continues his story, and as Shakespeare said: “Not marble nor the gilded monuments of princes shall outlive this powerful rhyme”. Nor shall gentrification.



You may also like

Can the buildings in which we learn impact our results?


THE Dreaming Spires conjures images of boating, stiff Pimm’s and the incredible buildings at Oxford University which inspired Victorian poet Matthew Arnold to create the epithet. It remains the most sought after university for students in the UK and beyond and it is no surprise that it currently occupies the top spot in the Times… Read More

Gentrification: good, bad, ugly or all three?


THE arguments for and against gentrification straddle social, political and historical barriers and aesthetic appeal alone can not determine their success. Inevitably if people with a degree of capital move into what might be termed working-class areas and subsequently transform the properties there will be winners and losers. The winners will be the property owners… Read More


Facade Experts
Façade Skins

Today’s façades reflect commercial intent, push design boundaries, change environments and showcase engineering capabilities. Are modern day façades merely used as a tool to showcase design progression and engineering egos? Are we considering the façade skin and the role it plays in influencing the urban landscapes of our future? With so much emphasis placed on… Read More

Facade Experts
Future façades

As the global economy tries to recover from its last dip, huge investments are being made in the construction industry, both in established and emerging markets. It’s anticipated that the volume of construction output will grow by more than 70% to achieve an annual worth of $15 trillion worldwide by 2025 (Source: Global Construction Perspectives… Read More

Get in touch

Call

0123 496 4016

or email
info@buildingtransformation.co.uk

Clients

Testimonials

Building Transformation’s unquestionable honesty and enthusiasm for ensuring the client receives the correct whole-life solution (rather than a quick fix) resulted in us being able to ensure the building was not only returned to its former glory, but will stay that way for years to come. I would recommend them to anyone.

Kenny Gash - Carillion Amey

The work provided by Building Transformation was excellent. Their product and building exteriors knowledge is detailed, comprehensive and practically applied to the client’s needs. They offer a professional, detailed, high-quality and customer- focused service which meets the short, medium and long-term needs of the client, and provides practical, cost-realistic advice.

Kerry Quinn - Echo Arena

Customer service is paramount to Building Transformation and they invested vast amounts of time in providing me with a programme to facilitate what was a very complex and time-specific programme of work for the site. The quality and level of support provided by Building Transformation is priceless to any client/contractor.

Marc Blow MCIOB MBIFM - Carillion Amey

The approach and advice on setting up the works at the Wolverhampton Civic Centre were first-class. Building Transformation’s attention to detail was excellent and the RAMS were followed meticulously to every detail. We were delighted with the works and service, and would not hesitate to use them again, nor hesitate to recommend them to any organisation.

Kevin Egginton - Wolverhampton Council

A 200,000 sq. ft., four-storey leisure venue in the heart of Nottingham city centre surrounded by major traffic routes needed work to be done overnight to deal with the traffic issues, while the site remained open throughout. The project took around three weeks to complete and went exceptionally well; the Building Transformation staff were flexible and able to work round dynamic operational issues. The clean was of a high standard and has made a significant different to the image of the building. A very difficult job done well.

Suzanne Green - Land Securities

May & Co have worked with Building Transformation on a number of projects which have included external building cleaning and refurbishment. They provided a great service, supported by the high level of documentation from the initial quotation to books and industry-related guidance, all relevant to our project.

Anton Theobald - May & Co

I am very satisfied in the manner the job was conducted. Also the level of cleaning provided and attention to detail is much appreciated.

Waqas Bin Tahir - Ibis Southampton

I am using Building Transformation’s work to help justify façade restoration works around our business.  They have produced excellent presentations on what can be achieved and is a brilliant piece of informed marketing that is helping slowly win people over in our business to take façade cleaning and restoration more seriously.

 Needless to say Building Transformation is a name that is now becoming known and respected.

Simon Attwood - Broadgate Estates Ltd.

Building Transformation gave great communication throughout our projects.
It
will be my pleasure to recommend Building Transformation.

Sarah Cameron - My Hotels Group

INTERESTED IN WORKING WITH US..?

Speak to one of our team today call..

0123 496 4016